The finale of The Mandalorian contained twists, turns, and a fair share of action to send off the series’ characters at the end of their first season. However, much of the action centered around the Mandalorian’s small travel companion and his pursuit by the remnants of the Empire. Despite the innumerable atrocities committed by the Empire, none were more prevalent in this chapter than the abuse suffered by Baby Yoda (we use this name for convenience and acknowledge that the life form may have no relation to Yoda whatsoever). So how exactly could the New Republic hold the Empire accountable in this scenario?
** Spoilers for The Mandalorian Ahead**
From the very first chapter, the Empire has been on an intense man(baby?)hunt for the young bounty. However, it was not until this chapter that they took him into their custody. At the end of the seventh chapter, we see two scout troopers gun down Kuiil before making off with Baby Yoda. This is in itself likely constitutes a crime.
Reckless Endangerment
Connecticut defines reckless endangerment as when a person, with extreme indifference to human life, recklessly engages in conduct which creates a risk of serious physical injury to another person. C.G.S. § 52a-63(a). Given that we see smoke rising from Kuiil’s body at the end of the seventh chapter it’s safe to assume that the scout troopers fired on him while he was attempting to get Baby Yoda back to the Razor Crest. The shots surely created a risk of serious physical injury to Baby Yoda as it clearly resulted in the death of Kuill. Not only could one of the shots have hit Baby Yoda, but the resulting crash (unseen, but assumed since Baby Yoda was found on the ground) could also have caused serious physical injury.
Risk of Injury to a Minor
It is not as clear if the scout troopers could be charged with risk of injury to a minor. Connecticut’s charge for risk of injury to a minor makes it a crime to place a child under the age of 16 in a situation where that child is at risk of life endangerment, injury to health or moral impairment, or to otherwise do anything likely to cause impairment to that child’s health or morals. C.G.S. § 53-21(a)(1). From chapters one and two, we know that the bounty was originally described to the Mandalorian as being 50 years old. Despite the fact that Baby Yoda objectively acts like a child, there is little question that he does not fit the age requirement under this law. As a result, and even though the shots fired at Kuiil could represent a risk of life endangerment to Baby Yoda, it is unlikely that the scout troopers could be charged with risk of injury to a minor.
Kidnapping
The more obvious charge here would be kidnapping as it was the scout trooper’s clear intent to whisk Baby Yoda back to the clutches of the Empire. Kidnapping in the first degree and the second degree both require the abduction of another person. C.G.S. §§ 53a-92a – 53a-94. However, to be kidnapping in the first degree the abduction has to be for a ransom, for inflicting physical injury or sexual abuse, for accomplishing the commission of a felony, or for terrorizing the victim or a third person. Id. It is clear from the troopers’ actions that Baby Yoda was abducted, as we see in the opening minutes of the eighth chapter. In that scene we see the scout trooper played by Jason Sudekis (now disowned by Second City Theater for his reprehensible actions) physically punch Baby Yoda.
At this point, not only can we establish the assault of Baby Yoda (the cause of physical injury to a person with the intent to cause such harm see C.G.S. § 53a-61), but this also satisfies the second element of kidnapping in the first degree since Baby Yoda certainly suffered from physical abuse. In fact, given that this kidnapping occurred with the use of firearms (regardless of how inaccurate any of the shots may be), this would constitute kidnapping in the first degree with a firearm. C.G.S. § 53a-92a. This charge carries a mandatory one year sentence that cannot be reduced.
Liability for the Empire
There is little doubt that the scout troopers could be held criminally liable for their actions against Baby Yoda. Were it not for the actions of the recommissioned nurse droid IG-11 those scout troopers would still be at large. As a result, they cannot be held responsible for their crimes. However, the Empire, or its remnants, may also be held liable for those same actions. Although most jurisdictions hesitate to extend vicarious liability to employers for the criminal acts of their employees, individual employers can still be held liable on conspiracy charges in certain circumstances. Conspiracy is described as follows:
A person is guilty of conspiracy when, with intent that conduct constituting a crime be performed, he agrees with one or more persons to engage in or cause the performance of such conduct, and any one of them commits an overt act in pursuance of such conspiracy. C.G.S. § 53a-48.
Presuming the scout troopers were acting under the orders of Moff Gideon when they absconded with, and subsequently held Baby Yoda, then it could be presumed that Moff Gideon had agreed with them to commit the kidnapping. In fact, although we do not see this in the show, it can be presumed that Moff Gideon ordered the scout troopers to obtain Baby Yoda. Given that the scout troopers were successful in their attempt to whisk away Baby Yoda, this would suffice in committing an overt act in pursuance of the kidnapping of Baby Yoda. Likewise, Moff Gideon, or anyone directing the actions of the scout troopers, could be held liable for conspiracy of other criminal acts of the scout troopers if it can be shown that persons supervising the scout troopers agreed to engage in such conduct. For example, since the scout trooper (Jason Sudeikis) only hit Baby Yoda in retaliation for being bitten (understandably), no one else in the Empire had conspired with the scout trooper to commit that act. Thus the elements for conspiracy to commit battery would not be met.
While Baby Yoda is safe, at least for the moment, we cannot ignore the great harm he was subjected to in the season finale at the hands of the Empire. It will be up to the New Republic to hold the last remnants of the Empire responsible for their actions. Even if Baby Yoda’s age doesn’t make him a child according to the risk of injury to a minor statute, the public will still not stand for this travesty.
